Data Centers are Problematic - Oregon Must Do More to Protect Our Land, Air and Water

Data Centers are Problematic and Oregon Must Do More

Over just a handful of years, we’ve seen the steady rise of data centers being built across the United States. Oregon has seen multiple facilities built to serve existing data needs for a range of companies. Much of the current push by Amazon, Microsoft, Meta, Google and others is about the future need related to the increased development of Artificial Intelligence.

Unfortunately, it seems that this current push to build large facilities across Oregon and beyond does not often contain a lot of human intelligence in regard to quality of life for people, or for the environment.

Data centers are built to store data at a massive scale. Large buildings with thousands of computer servers hum through day and night to feed our current fascination with social media, but even more are being planned and built to meet the projected widespread use of AI.

In Oregon, as in other areas, data centers consume vast amounts of water, often in water-scarce areas. They also consume immense amounts of electricity – so much so that nuclear generation facilities are being restarted or are being contemplated to meet the oncoming demand. The outlook by investors for companies like Portland General Electric is rosy. Their analyses make note of the increase in Data Centers in Oregon, with the higher electricity demand leading to larger profits – which results in higher stock value.

Many of these data centers must keep their servers between 70-80 degrees and to do so their cooling systems can use millions of gallons of cooling water a day, on par with large pulp and paper plants of old. In many places this creates a very real issue related to available water for municipal needs and agriculture. Then layer on the electricity for the servers and their cooling systems and we get something that is anathema to curbing global climate change.

Data centers do not provide many jobs after they are constructed, and ironically the increased use of AI that data centers support, will result in further job reductions for humans. We see this already, at companies like Intel who already announced significant layoffs with the idea of increased AI usage – which results in more demand for data centers.

In many places around the US people are making their voices heard about proposed or existing data centers, and their negative impacts. On the edge of Duluth MN, the town of Hermantown has seen a proposal for an AI data center. In what is almost customary for such situations, the City council was primed by the data center company to push through a zoning change for the center, and even signed non-disclosure agreements in order to dodge transparency. Thankfully in this case, local folks had just enough time to push back – resulting in the company pulling back its proposal. In Oregon there are multiple data centers, with too little scrutiny in regard how they were developed, and where they were placed. All of them use massive amounts of water and electricity.

It would seem putting some significant curbs on this growth makes sense (just as it would with AI itself), and carefully scrutinizing data center proposals. If and when they are built, data center owners and developers should make very significant contributions to the protection of land and water through non-profit organizations, and in local and regional government. Protecting our creeks, rivers, and ground water is essential. Further, the carbon imprint of these facilities must be carefully incorporated.

Oregon would be well-served by leadership that understands the risks presented to people, and the environment by data centers. Oregon should take bolder action in the face of this new issue. In a time where “streamlining” is a popular buzzword in regard to increasing business opportunities in Oregon, we must be exceedingly careful.  Oregon needs to consider first and foremost the well-being of its people in regard to Data Center placement, and develop a coherent strategy to ensure the protection of our water, air and land. 

Travis Williams is a long-time Willamette River conservationist, who today leads the Willamette River Preservation Trust. wrtrust.org

Spring 2020

Over the past few weeks, to stay healthy and to keep some projects moving, I’ve been lucky to grab my canoe, and get on the river. From one Greenway property to another, each week I’ve been able to take some time, use power tools, work on invasive weeds, work on trails, investigate the occasional riverside pollution issue - and to make progress along the river. In doing this, I also realize that it is not possible for a lot of people, and that time, and intent, is a privilege - work worn, passion induced or otherwise.

These instances have enabled me to view the seasonal changes over the months, from the slightly warmer grey of March, to the affirmative sun and flowers of April and May/ The recent weeks have witnessed the rush of migratory song birds through May and now into June.

Red Osier Dogwood.

Red Osier Dogwood.

It is encouraging to see that more and more people are able to get outside. Obviously things are now tough on multiple levels, and that has to change. Perhaps the quiet of a local park, or a nearby natural area can provide some balance for you as well.

Wilson’s Warbler - Norwood, May 14

Wilson’s Warbler - Norwood, May 14

For me, nature has been a welcome agent of calm amid the storm. As a Type 1 Diabetic, I try to find different ways to keep busy, and keep my body moving. Even for an ED of a non profit, I work hard to keep my hands of the tools of the field work. Norwood Island is one of these places that keeps me busy.

Bobcat - location kept secret.

Bobcat - location kept secret.

Twenty years ago I started my work along the river. In a normal year that would be something to celebrate. At this point, next year is likely a better option.

I hope all of you are doing as well as can be during this tough time. We need change, on many fronts.

Travis

Summer Flows

Not long ago, the gentle heat arrived - what feels like the official start of summer. Over the past few weeks I've been watching the migratory song birds arrive along the willow coated fringes of the river. All of the native plants have come alive, sending their bright flowers upward toward the sun. This to a significant degree is what we all wait for. 

Osprey have been back to the North for over a month, and now they seek food for their chicks which are evident along the river.

I've also been very watchful of the river itself in terms of flow, specifically how much water is traveling north. I've been doing the same with other rivers, and thinking about when it is best to travel them, my thinking built around the sometimes tricky balance between fun, safety, and logistical realities involved in paddling canoes, kayaks, rafts and drift boats. 

DSC_5094.jpg

By Memorial Day water levels had dropped, but still not down to the low flows of high summer. With the arrival of late June the river approaches low summer flows, and for the first time I can see the river bottom with regularity on the upper river. Tiny juga snails are evident on the river rocks, as well as the many stoneflies, and of course freshwater mussels. Fish, from suckers to trout are spotted whisking along the gravel bars, and Osprey dive frequently toward their prey. Everything is bounded still by elements of the wreckage of the April floods.

Amongst the mussel shells, I can see the occasional live mussel holding fast to the river bottom.

Wood debris, human garbage, and growing things can be seen in the masses of root wads and tree trunks blended together in places along the riverside. All of them are testaments to the power of the water just a couple of months back.

While the calendar full of work and life events is packed, it is nice to know that this summer flow will be around for a while longer, meandering between barriers small and large as we arc toward summer solstice and the many warm, sunlit days ahead.

DSC_1549.jpg

Two Months Past Winter Solstice

High and wide, the river is rich with the silty brown water of winter. It is late February. All of the leaves have long since fallen. Here and there a few brown ones are left scattered on the ground.  Cottonwood, ash, and willow interwoven into the grey rock and brown silt of the floodplain..  

Multiple times the river has risen this winter, and in doing so it has scoured old side channels and backed up the dead end sloughs with many feet of temporary flow. To the untrained eye this place is cold, barren of food, and may even seem fraught with risk from the power of the water. In fact it may seem that little remains alive along the river. Upon closer inspection, a corner has been turned in the season - if only for the presence of more light at the end of each day. Perhaps in anticipation of warming days, even if by a few degrees, the presence of wild things is evident.  

On the riverside natural area where I spend time, Norwood Island, a trail weaves along the riverside. It tells a lot about what goes on here. The deer and coyote first created it. Later the rabbit, turkey, beaver, and raccoon discovered it.  Fourteen year old pines, some gaining what might be called their sub-adult girth, create a small forest of about 30 acres in the mid part of the island's east side. Here the trail twists along next to these trees, working its way downstream. I can see something has been walking on this path. 

Rounded pellets of deer scat dot the ground in a small collection at the base of a snowberry bush. Deer are common along the floodplain, yet in all of my time on this island I have only seen one once. Not seeing many deer may seem ironic given how frequently they are seen along roadsides and backyards in the suburbs. Yet here this creature may well be more guarded, backing off against the occasional human incursion that is easy to detect. 

I recently captured an image of a deer on this island -  a little doe. In the midst of the rain, sleet, and high water of the winter this little animal had made her way, surviving on her own. At dusk she picks her way across the island, nibbling forward. Sometimes she wanders in the pre-dawn darkness. Her teeth cut at the near dormant plants as she walks, pauses to inspect the offerings of the trail, then chewing stems and stalks with what seems almost like patience. After capturing the image of this little animal, I find myself wondering about her. 

 

She who nibbles. 

She who nibbles. 

Digestion is her strong suit. She can eat almost anything that grows on the island. There is a lot available to this animal and her kin across the 90 acres. It may not be easy, but her system can break the plant matter down and convert it to energy. In a strange way that fact is very reassuring to me. I wonder about the times I've worked on this island, with loud buzzing machines cutting away at invasive plants.  Any angst I feel about impacting the creatures that live on this island with my noise is put at ease to some degree, knowing that the work will result in something better for native plants and animals here. Removing the non-native weeds that crowd out native plants can result in improved habitat for a range of species, from fish and insects, to birds and bees. 

Coyote scat is also evident here and there on the island.  This animal  I've never seen in person at Norwood. It seems there is no pack of coyote here, just a solitary individual, or maybe two. On summer nights there has never been a call to detect, unlike other natural areas along river where I've heard the barking and yapping. In one extraordinary case I was serenaded by two packs on either side of the river. So far at this place there has been no chorus of animals raising their wild voices to the moon. 

At one point recently I hid a remote sensing camera near where I know at least one coyote travels on the island. After just a few days II was rewarded with a very sweet image. What caught my eye most is how much this beautiful animal blends into the scenery - nearly becoming one with the dead twigs and grass of winter. 

Down a familiar path, Norwood Island, Willamette River. 

Down a familiar path, Norwood Island, Willamette River. 

It is hard to know where this animal spends its time on the island, though there are some signs of where it has been. What is notable is that this creature was photographed near where the little doe has been many times. Yet, having spent a good amount of time there, I think the two are using the same path for similar purposes. My guess is that this watchful canine is drawn around the island more by the presence of rabbits that frequently skitter from clumps of Nootka Rose and Douglas Spirea to the stands of Himalayan Blackberry on the island.

This place is not all that far from many people, yet here on this winter day, it feels far away. It can be dangerous traveling these high flows in winter. It can be dangerous being a deer living on the floodplains of a big river. It can be dangerous being a coyote along the river.